Sticky space
Smencils $1 each! Up to 50% profit Click here

Online Fundraiser vs. Face-to-Face Cookie Dough Selling for Schools: Which Works Better?

By Clay Boggess on Nov 21, 2026
Image
Online Fundraiser vs. Face-to-Face Cookie Dough Selling for Schools

 

Face-to-face brochure selling earns a flat 40% profit on Otis Spunkmeyer cookie dough and works best for groups with many sellers. Frozen products arrive at your school 3 to 4 weeks after ordering. An online-only store eliminates order forms, cash counting, and delivery logistics. However, buyers pay for shipping, and your group's profit scales from 25% to 40% based on total volume. Many schools combine both with the Otis program, where an online store adds 800 or more non-frozen items. Choose based on how many people will really participate, how soon you need to finish, and how much hands-on work your volunteers can handle.

Quick stats: Otis Spunkmeyer brochure profit is 40% with $0 to start. Cookie Dough Online profit is 25% to 40% by volume. An online-only store sets up in 3 to 5 business days, and a brochure fundraiser delivers 3 to 4 weeks after order forms are submitted. On both pages, 46% of participants register on day one and 80% of those who register sell, averaging $100 per seller.

Cookie dough is one of the most popular school fundraising products, and groups now choose between two very different ways to sell it. In a face-to-face fundraiser, students show a brochure, take orders from neighbors and relatives, collect money, and deliver the dough. In an online fundraiser, supporters order from home using online links.

Both can work. The right choice depends on your group's size, timeline, and the hands-on work your volunteers can handle. This guide compares the two side by side, using the terms Big Fundraising Ideas publishes.

For more on the product itself, see our cookie dough fundraisers, the Otis Spunkmeyer cookie dough fundraiser, and School Cookie Dough Fundraisers 101.

Three Ways to Sell Cookie Dough: At a Glance

You can sell face-to-face with a brochure, sell online only, or combine a brochure with an online store.

 

Face-to-Face Brochure

Brochure Plus Online Store

Online Only

Program

Otis Spunkmeyer brochure

Otis Spunkmeyer brochure and online store

Cookie Dough Online

How buyers order

On a paper order form, and pay up front

On a paper order form, or in your online store

In your online store at checkout

Profit

40%

40% on brochure and online sales

25% to 40% by products sold

Upfront cost

$0

$0

$0, with a $50 fee if you sell fewer than 50 products

Minimums

No minimum order

No minimum order

No minimum order, but at least 5 participants

Who pays shipping

Free at 350+ frozen products, else $1.00 per product

Same, and buyers pay online shipping

Buyers pay, or choose ship-to-group for a 5% fee

Setup time

7 to 10 business days for supplies

7 to 10 business days for supplies

3 to 5 business days

Delivery

To your group, 3 to 4 weeks after order forms

Brochure: to your group. Online: ships to buyers within 2 business days

Ships to buyers within 3 to 5 business days after purchase

From the Otis Spunkmeyer and Cookie Dough Online pages, November 2026.

Not sure which fits? Try our fundraiser finder and the side-by-side comparisons, and see brochure fundraisers and online fundraisers.

How Face-to-Face Cookie Dough Selling Works

Students show a brochure, collect orders and money, and your group pays an invoice and keeps the rest.

In a brochure fundraiser, each participant receives a brochure, an order form, and a money collection envelope. They ask neighbors, family, and friends to order, collect payment, and turn in the forms and money. You deposit the money, submit your orders, receive a sales report, and pay the invoice we send. You keep the rest as profit.

Step

What Happens

1. Get started

Submit the Start a Fundraiser form and sign an agreement. Supplies take 7 to 10 business days

2. Sell

Participants take orders with a brochure for about two weeks, and buyers pay up front

3. Collect

Participants turn in order forms and money by the end date

4. Submit

You deposit the money and submit your orders. We send a sales report and an invoice

5. Receive

Product ships to your group about 3 to 4 weeks after we receive your order forms, prepacked by the seller

6. Deliver

Participants deliver to their buyers, and you keep the rest as profit

What It Costs

  • Starting costs are $0, and there is no minimum order.
  • We do not charge for supplies upfront. However, a $0.75 supply fee per enrolled participant ($0.40 from January through June) applies if your average sale per enrolled participant drops to $8 or less.
  • Shipping is free if your group sells 350 or more frozen products. Below that, it is $1.00 per product.
  • Brochure customers do not pay sales tax.

How Buyers Pay

Buyers can pay by check, cash, money order, cashier's check, or with their phone. Because money is collected with each order, plan how your group will count, deposit, and track it. See our guides on collecting fundraising money promptly and how a school gets paid after a fundraiser.

See how to collect fundraising money promptly and how a school gets paid after a fundraiser.

? ?

Have
questions?

 

Schedule a FREE meeting
with a fundraising specialist

Schedule a Free Video Call

How Online-Only Cookie Dough Selling Works

Participants share a link, supporters order online, and your group receives a profit payment: no order forms, cash, or deliveries.

With Cookie Dough Online, fundraising is completely digital. We build your online store for free, meaning zero upfront costs, zero inventory, and no face-to-face selling. Participants register, get a personal link, and share it by text, email, and social media. Supporters can also shop 500+ premium products, starting at $12.00.

Products Your Group Sells

Your Profit

1 to 9

25%

10 to 29

30%

30 to 49

35%

50 or more

40%

From the Cookie Dough Online page, November 2026. You also receive 70% of online donations, which do not count toward the product tiers. A $50 administrative fee is deducted from your profit if your group sells fewer than 50 products.

The Details That Matter

  • Setup: At least 3 to 5 business days after you submit the Start a Fundraiser form and sign the agreement
  • Length: Two weeks by default, and your store closes the next business day after the sale ends.
  • Group size: At least 5 participants, with no minimum order
  • Payment: Your profit payment is processed within 10 business days of your store's closing
  • Shipping: Orders generally ship within 3 to 5 business days after purchase, directly to buyers in the 48 lower states
  • Sales tax: Customers do not pay sales tax on online orders
  • Limit: You can run only one online store at a time

See the Cookie Dough Online store for the current terms, and the Amazing Dough brochure if you want to add a print brochure.

What Buyers Pay for Shipping, and Why It Matters

Frozen cookie dough costs more to ship than most products. Buyers pay shipping, so offer a lower-cost option.

Cookie dough ships frozen, so shipping to a buyer's home is a real cost. On the online-only store, a single tub costs $14.98 to ship to a home, and a two-tub order costs $19.98. Orders of five or more products get a shipping discount.

Products in the Order

Ship to Home

Average Shipping per Product

1

$14.98

$14.98

2

$19.98

$9.99

3

$24.96

$8.32

4

$29.95

$7.49

5

$24.95

$4.99

6

$29.94

$4.99

7

$34.93

$4.99

The ship-to-group option can help. Buyers pay a 5% processing fee instead of home shipping, and their order ships to your group, prepacked by the seller. For example, two $20 tubs cost $40 plus $19.98 in shipping, or $59.98, to ship to a home. Shipping to your group costs the buyer $40 plus 5%, or $42.

Products Sold (With Ship-to-Group)

Profit

Shipping to Your Group

Up to 149

25%

Deducted from your profit

150 to 199

30%

Free, in qualifying states

200 to 299

35%

Free, in qualifying states

300 to 399

38%

Free, in qualifying states

400 or more

40%

Free, in qualifying states

From the Cookie Dough Online page. We recommend the ship-to-group option for buyers close to you, because your group delivers those orders.

EXPERT INSIGHT: Do Not Let Shipping Surprise Your Supporters

Most online cookie dough sales are lost at checkout, not in the sales pitch. A relative agrees to buy one twenty-dollar tub, then sees a fourteen-dollar shipping charge and closes the page. The fix is to plan for shipping before your sale starts. First, tell sellers that the cheapest order is a larger one, because the shipping discount starts at five products and the average cost per product falls. Second, add the ship-to-group option so local supporters can avoid shipping entirely and pay only a small processing fee. Third, set the expectation in your message, such as 'Orders of five or more ship for much less.' Fourth, send your online link strictly to out-of-town family who can't buy in person. Use the paper brochure for nearby supporters so they get free delivery. That mix keeps each buyer on the cheapest path for them. It also protects your profit, because a buyer who completes the order is worth more than one who admires the price and leaves. Treat shipping as part of the product, and explain it up front.

Profit Compared: Two Illustrations

Both methods can earn well. What changes is how many products your sellers move and how buyers get them.

Here are two simple illustrations. In a brochure fundraiser, 60 participants who each sell 10 items at an average price of about $22 sell 600 items for $13,200 in sales, and your group keeps 40%, which is $5,280.

For online-only stores, Big Fundraising Ideas reports that 46% of participants register on day one. Of those registered, 80% successfully make a sale, averaging $100 per seller. If 60 participants register and 80% of them sell, that is 48 sellers and $4,800 in sales. At $20 per tub, that is about 240 tubs, so your profit would be about $1,920 at 40%, or about $1,680 at the 35% ship-to-group tier.

 

Face-to-Face Brochure

Online Only

Assumption

60 participants sell 10 items each at about $22

60 participants register, and 80% sell about $100 each

Gross sales

$13,200

$4,800

Group profit

$5,280 at 40%

About $1,920 at 40%, or $1,680 at 35% with ship-to-group

Buyer shipping cost

None for brochure delivery to your group

Home shipping, or a 5% processing fee

Illustrations only. They use different assumptions, such as 10 items per participant versus the reported $100 average per online seller, so they are not a prediction or a direct comparison. Your results will differ.

For a fuller breakdown of the brochure numbers, see how much a school can make from an Otis Spunkmeyer fundraiser.

How Long Does Each Method Take?

An online-only store can finish in about four weeks. A brochure fundraiser needs roughly six and a half to eight weeks from signing to delivery.

Stage

Face-to-Face Brochure

Online Only

Setup

Supplies ship 7 to 10 business days after you sign

Store is set up in 3 to 5 business days

Selling

Two weeks by default

Two weeks by default

Close

Online store, if used, closes 1 to 5 days after order forms

Store closes the next business day after the sale

Product arrives

Delivered to your group 3 to 4 weeks after we receive your order forms

Ships to buyers within 3 to 5 business days after purchase

You are paid

Invoice credit or payment after orders are processed

Profit payment within 10 business days of closing

Approximate total

About 6.5 to 8 weeks

About 4 weeks

Approximate, computed from the stages above. Delivery dates are not guaranteed.

If you are racing a deadline, see holiday fundraising products and fall fundraising ideas.

Combining Both: The Otis Spunkmeyer Hybrid

With the Otis Spunkmeyer program, you choose paper brochures, an online store, or both, at a flat 40%.

The Otis Spunkmeyer fundraiser lets groups choose traditional paper brochures, a custom online store, or both. Selling online adds a second way for your group to raise money, and your online store includes additional products not found in the brochure. The brochure features the cookie dough, and the online store offers 800+ non-frozen premium gifts and treats starting at $11.00.

  • Flat Profit: Earn 40% on all brochure and online sales, plus keep 70% of any flat online donations.
  • One Invoice: Your online profit is credited toward your brochure sales invoice, and we send a payment if online profit exceeds the invoice.
  • Reach: Out-of-town relatives can shop online, and nearby buyers can order from the brochure.
  • Registration is Key: 46% register on the first day, and 80% of registered participants sell, averaging $100 per seller. Participants who add a photo are ten times more likely to get supporters.

Add incentives that fit your school. See additional fundraising incentive ideas and how to improve school fundraiser participation.

Face-to-Face vs Online: Pros and Cons

Face-to-face selling works best with many hands. Online selling works best when you need less work or a faster timeline.

 

Face-to-Face Brochure

Online Only

Pros

Flat 40% profit. No shipping cost for buyers. Product delivered to your group, prepacked by seller. Works well with many sellers and a school-wide kickoff

No order forms, cash, or deliveries. Faster timeline. Reaches out-of-town supporters. Real-time tracking

Cons

Collecting and counting money. Longer timeline of roughly 6.5 to 8 weeks. Delivery day logistics for frozen dough

Buyers pay shipping. Profit starts at 25% and reaches 40% only at 50 or more products. A $50 fee applies under 50 products. Minimum of 5 participants

Best for

Large schools, PTOs, and groups with volunteers and time

Small groups, short timelines, and groups with a wide network of supporters

How to Choose: A Quick Decision Guide

Choose by sellers, time, and hands-on work. When in doubt, combine a brochure with an online store.

If Your Group...

Consider

Has many sellers and a school-wide kickoff

A brochure fundraiser, plus an online store for out-of-town supporters

Has a short timeline

An online-only store, which can finish in about 4 weeks

Has limited volunteers to count money and sort deliveries

An online-only store

Has a close local community and wants no shipping cost for buyers

A brochure fundraiser with delivery to your group

Has fewer than 5 participants

A brochure fundraiser, because online-only needs at least 5 participants

Wants the widest reach

Both, through the Otis Spunkmeyer program

For more ways to plan, see how to fundraise for school, online donation fundraisers, and our comparison of cookie dough and frozen food fundraisers. For a cookie dough pairing idea, see cookie dough and wrapping paper fundraisers.

Delivery Day, Safety, and Storage

  • Plan for freezers or coolers before delivery day. Otis cookie dough can safely sit at room temperature for 6 to 8 hours and can be refrigerated for up to two weeks after opening.
  • Cookie dough can stay frozen for up to one year, and it can be thawed and refrozen to extend its shelf life.
  • Students should sell with a parent or guardian and follow school policy. See school fundraising safety tips and school food fundraiser rules.

EXPERT INSIGHT: Choose by Who Will Actually Sell, Not by What Sounds Easier

Groups often pick online because it sounds like less work, or brochure because it feels traditional. The better question is who will actually sell. Online selling wins when students prefer sharing links, supporters live out of town, and volunteers don't have time to count cash. Brochure works when your sellers can reach nearby neighbors in person, and your group has the volunteers to collect envelopes, deposit the money, and sort the deliveries. Look at your last fundraiser. If participation was strong and your parents were involved, a brochure with a school-wide kickoff may suit you, and an online store adds out-of-town reach. If participation was thin, or the sale has to finish quickly, an online-only store keeps the work small. Also count your sellers honestly. The online-only store needs at least five participants, and an online-only store under fifty products carries a fifty-dollar fee. Whichever you choose, hold a kickoff and push for early registration, because the first day of registration is the best predictor of how the sale will go.

Ready to Choose?

Big Fundraising Ideas can help you match a cookie dough fundraiser to your group's size, timeline, and goals. Explore the Otis Spunkmeyer fundraiser or the online cookie dough store described above, or browse all school fundraisers. To talk it through, contact our team or call (866) 980-9930, Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. CST.

Frequently Asked Questions About Online and Face-to-Face Cookie Dough Fundraisers

Is an online cookie dough fundraiser as profitable as face-to-face selling?

It depends on the program. In the Otis Spunkmeyer program, brochure and online sales both earn a flat 40%. The online-only Cookie Dough store uses a tiered profit structure (25% to 40%) based on total volume. A $50 fee applies if your group sells fewer than 50 products. Shipping costs paid by buyers can also affect how many orders you get.

How much profit does an online-only cookie dough fundraiser earn?

The online-only store pays 25% on 1-9 products, 30% on 10-29, 35% on 30-49, and 40% on 50 or more, plus 70% of donations. A $50 administrative fee is deducted if your group sells fewer than 50 products. With the ship-to-group option, the tiers run from 25% up to 40% at 400 or more products.

How much does a face-to-face brochure cookie dough fundraiser earn?

The Otis Spunkmeyer brochure fundraiser earns 40% on brochure and online sales, with no minimum order and $0 to start. For example, 60 participants selling 10 items at about $22 each sell 600 items for $13,200, and your group keeps $5,280. Real results vary with how many items each participant sells.

Who pays shipping on an online cookie dough fundraiser?

Buyers pay. In the online-only store, shipping a single tub to a home is $14.98, and a two-tub order is $19.98. Buyers can instead ship to your group and pay a 5% processing fee, and your group may receive free shipping if it qualifies and sells 150 or more products.

How long does each type of cookie dough fundraiser take?

An online-only store takes 3 to 5 business days to set up, runs for two weeks by default, and ships orders within 3 to 5 business days after purchase. A brochure fundraiser needs 7 to 10 business days for supplies, runs for two weeks, and delivers 3 to 4 weeks after we receive your order forms.

Can we run a brochure and an online store together?

Yes. The Otis Spunkmeyer program lets you choose paper brochures, a custom online store, or both. The online store adds 800 or more non-frozen items starting at $11.00 and gives supporters a second way to buy. Online profit is credited toward your brochure invoice.

Do we collect money in an online cookie dough fundraiser?

No. In an online-only store, buyers pay at checkout, and your group receives a profit payment within 10 business days after the store closes. In a brochure fundraiser, participants collect money with each order; you deposit it, pay your invoice, and keep the rest as profit.

What is the minimum order or group size?

Neither fundraiser has a minimum order. The online-only store requires a group of at least 5 participants. A brochure fundraiser has no minimum order, and shipping is free when your group sells 350 or more frozen products; below that, there is a $1.00-per-product fee.

Do cookie dough fundraisers charge sales tax?

Big Fundraising Ideas says that most brochure customers do not pay sales tax, and most customers do not pay sales tax on online orders. Tax rules can vary by state and situation, so confirm anything specific to your group with your business office.

How does frozen cookie dough get to buyers?

In a brochure fundraiser, orders ship to your group 3 to 4 weeks after order forms are received; the company prepacks them, and participants deliver to their buyers. Otis cookie dough can stay at room temperature for 6 to 8 hours, so plan for freezers or coolers on delivery day. Online-only orders ship from our warehouse to buyers' homes, or to your group if buyers choose that option.

Need
More Info?

 

Reach out today for a FREE consultation
with an expert

Contact Us Now

Author Bio Clay Boggess, Author

Clay Boggess has been designing fundraising programs for schools and various nonprofit organizations throughout the US since 1999. He’s helped administrators, teachers, and outside support entities such as PTAs and PTOs raise millions of dollars. Clay is an owner and partner at Big Fundraising Ideas.